الرئيسية

لخّصلي

خدمة تلخيص النصوص العربية أونلاين،قم بتلخيص نصوصك بضغطة واحدة من خلال هذه الخدمة

نتيجة التلخيص (50%)

U.S. citizen Mabelle de la Rosa Dann recruited Peruvian victim P.C. to come to the United States as her nanny and housekeeper, promising P.C. that she would be paid $600 per month plus free room and board in exchange for working five days per week during regular business hours.Author: Human Trafficking Database of the University of Michigan Law School Keywords

Acts: Recruitment Harbouring Means: Threat or use of force or other forms of coercion Deception Abuse of power or a position of vulnerability Purpose of Exploitation: Servitude Form of Trafficking: Transnational Sector in which exploitation takes place: Domestic servitude Cross-Cutting Issues

Gender and sexuality considerations

Details

o Female principal offender Procedural Information

Legal System: Common Law Latest Court Ruling: Appellate Court Type of Proceeding: Criminal 1st Instance: Court: United States District Court for the Northern District of California Date of decision: 2010 2nd Instance: Court: United States Circuit Court for the Ninth Circuit Date of decision: 9 May 2011 Victims / Plaintiffs in the first instance

Victim: P.C. Gender: Female Nationality: Peruvian Defendants / Respondents in the first instance

Defendant: Mabelle de la Rosa Dann Gender: Female Nationality: American Legal Reasoning: Dann was charged with conspiracy to commit visa fraud, visa fraud, forced labour, unlawful conduct regarding documents in furtherance of servitude, and harbouring an illegal alien for the purpose of private financial gain.In doing so, the court considered the legislative history of the TVPA (2000) and noted that "legislative history suggests that Congress, in passing the act, intended to reach cases in which persons are held in a condition of servitude through nonviolent coercion.'" (2011 WL 2937944, *8 (C.A.9 (Cal.)) (citing the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000 ? 102(b)(13)). The Circuit Court also noted that "not all bad employer-employee relationships or even bad employer-immigrant nanny relationships will constitute forced labour.1594(a) Charge details: Forced Labour Verdict: Guilty Term of Imprisonment: 5 years Compensation / Payment to Victim: Yes 123740 USD (100,000-500,000 USD) Fine / Payment to State: Yes 600 USD (Up to 10,000 USD) Appellate Decision: In Part Dann appealed the convictions of forced labour and related offenses of document servitude and harbouring an alien for financial gain and three sentence enhancements.The Circuit Court affirmed Dann's conviction but declined to reach the merits of the first sentence enhancement because it didn't affect the federal sentencing guidelines offense level, affirmed the second one, and affirmed the third.Commentary and Significant Features

The Circuit Court discussed the forced labour conviction since Dann argued that her relationship with P.C. removed it from the forced labour statute.Court

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit Sources / Citations

Circuit Court Opinion: United States v. Mabelle De La Rosa Dann, No. 10-10191 (9th Cir., July 22, 2011).Dann appealed the convictions of forced labour and related offenses of document servitude and harbouring an alien for financial gain and her sentence enhancements.1592 Charge details: Unlawful Conduct Regarding Documents in Furtherance of Servitude Verdict: Guilty Legislation / Statute / Code: 18 U.S.C. ?This document along with P.C.'s Peruvian identification and passport were found by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in Dann's clothing drawer.1546 Charge details: Visa Fraud Verdict: Guilty Legislation / Statute / Code: 8 U.S.C. ?...371 and ?

النص الأصلي

U.S. citizen Mabelle de la Rosa Dann recruited Peruvian victim P.C. to come to the United States as her nanny and housekeeper, promising P.C. that she would be paid $600 per month plus free room and board in exchange for working five days per week during regular business hours. But once P.C. arrived, Dann seized P.C.'s passport, and refused to pay her for two years. P.C. regularly worked from 6 a.m. until 9 p.m., and was prohibited from communicating with others or listening to Spanish language radio and television. At one point, Dann told P.C. that she owed her $13,000 and needed to work to repay the debt. Dann also asked P.C. to sign a document stating she had been paid minimum wage. This document along with P.C.’s Peruvian identification and passport were found by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in Dann’s clothing drawer.
At trial, Dann argued that P.C.’s testimony was tainted by her incentive to lie to obtain a T-visa and remain in the United States and that their relationship was similar to that of two female family members. The Government, in contrast, presented a case where Dann is a woman in need of free or cheap labor, who exploited P.C. and held her in slave-like conditions. The appellate court notes that because Dann was convicted, her story has been judged as less credible by the jury.
Commentary and Significant Features


The Circuit Court discussed the forced labour conviction since Dann argued that her relationship with P.C. removed it from the forced labour statute. In doing so, the court considered the legislative history of the TVPA (2000) and noted that “legislative history suggests that Congress, in passing the act, intended to reach cases in which persons are held in a condition of servitude through nonviolent coercion.'" (2011 WL 2937944, *8 (C.A.9 (Cal.)) (citing the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000 § 102(b)(13)).
The Circuit Court also noted that “not all bad employer-employee relationships or even bad employer-immigrant nanny relationships will constitute forced labour. . . . the threat of harm must be serious” and the employer must have “intended to cause the victim to believe that she would suffer serious harm – from the vantage point of the victim – if she did not continue to work.” The key under section 1589, according to the court, is not just “that serious harm was threatened but that the employer intended the victim to believe that such harm would befall her.”
The Court considered the threats from Dann and asked whether from the perspective of P.C., these harms were sufficiently serious to compel her to remain with Dann. They answered that the threats of financial harm, reputational harm, immigration harm, and harm to Dann’s children were sufficient to compel a reasonable person in P.C.’s position to remain with Dann and so Dann intended to make P.C. believe she would suffer serious harm if PC ceased working for Dann.
Author:
Human Trafficking Database of the University of Michigan Law School
Keywords


Acts:
Recruitment
Harbouring
Means:
Threat or use of force or other forms of coercion
Deception
Abuse of power or a position of vulnerability
Purpose of Exploitation:
Servitude
Form of Trafficking:
Transnational
Sector in which exploitation takes place:
Domestic servitude
Cross-Cutting Issues


Gender and sexuality considerations


Details


• Female principal offender
Procedural Information


Legal System: Common Law
Latest Court Ruling: Appellate Court
Type of Proceeding: Criminal
1st Instance:
Court: United States District Court for the Northern District of California
Date of decision: 2010
2nd Instance:
Court: United States Circuit Court for the Ninth Circuit
Date of decision: 9 May 2011
Victims / Plaintiffs in the first instance


Victim: P.C.
Gender: Female
Nationality: Peruvian
Defendants / Respondents in the first instance


Defendant: Mabelle de la Rosa Dann
Gender: Female
Nationality: American
Legal Reasoning:
Dann was charged with conspiracy to commit visa fraud, visa fraud, forced labour, unlawful conduct regarding documents in furtherance of servitude, and harbouring an illegal alien for the purpose of private financial gain. She was found guilty of all five counts in a jury trial and sentenced to 60 months’ imprisonment. The District Court also ordered her to pay restitution to P.C. in the sum of $123,740.23. Because P.C. was living in a shelter and needed money immediately at the time, the court also ordered Dann to turn over to P.C. any accrued child support payments that Dann received from her ex husband.
Dann appealed the convictions of forced labour and related offenses of document servitude and harbouring an alien for financial gain and her sentence enhancements.
Charges / Claims / Decisions


Defendant: Mabelle de la Rosa Dann
Legislation / Statute / Code:
18 U.S.C. § 371 and § 1546
Charge details:
Conspiracy to Commit Visa Fraud
Verdict: Guilty
Legislation / Statute / Code:
18 U.S.C. § 1546
Charge details:
Visa Fraud
Verdict: Guilty
Legislation / Statute / Code:
8 U.S.C. § 1324(a)(1)(iii) and (B)(i)
Charge details:
Harbouring an Illegal Alien for Private Financial Gain
Verdict: Guilty
Legislation / Statute / Code:
18 USC § 1592
Charge details:
Unlawful Conduct Regarding Documents in Furtherance of Servitude
Verdict: Guilty
Legislation / Statute / Code:
18 U.S.C. § 1589 and § 1594(a)
Charge details:
Forced Labour
Verdict: Guilty
Term of Imprisonment:
5 years
Compensation / Payment to Victim:
Yes 123740 USD (100,000-500,000 USD)
Fine / Payment to State:
Yes 600 USD (Up to 10,000 USD)
Appellate Decision:
In Part
Dann appealed the convictions of forced labour and related offenses of document servitude and harbouring an alien for financial gain and three sentence enhancements.
The Circuit Court affirmed Dann’s conviction but declined to reach the merits of the first sentence enhancement because it didn’t affect the federal sentencing guidelines offense level, affirmed the second one, and affirmed the third.
The Circuit Court did, however, reverse the District Court’s restitution order. The case raised the question of whether child support arrearages belong to the criminal defendant such that the District Court could order them to the victim through a restitution order. Under California case law, the money received for child support does not belong to Dann, but rather to her minor children, and so it cannot be assigned to the victim.
Court


United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Sources / Citations


Circuit Court Opinion: United States v. Mabelle De La Rosa Dann, No. 10-10191 (9th Cir., July 22, 2011).
District Court Docket Number: 4:08−CR−00390
Related Civil Action: 2010 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 97856


تلخيص النصوص العربية والإنجليزية أونلاين

تلخيص النصوص آلياً

تلخيص النصوص العربية والإنجليزية اليا باستخدام الخوارزميات الإحصائية وترتيب وأهمية الجمل في النص

تحميل التلخيص

يمكنك تحميل ناتج التلخيص بأكثر من صيغة متوفرة مثل PDF أو ملفات Word أو حتي نصوص عادية

رابط دائم

يمكنك مشاركة رابط التلخيص بسهولة حيث يحتفظ الموقع بالتلخيص لإمكانية الإطلاع عليه في أي وقت ومن أي جهاز ماعدا الملخصات الخاصة

مميزات أخري

نعمل علي العديد من الإضافات والمميزات لتسهيل عملية التلخيص وتحسينها

آخر التلخيصات

١- زَتَةُ بِنْت...

١- زَتَةُ بِنْتْ فِى الْعاشِرَةِ مِنَ ٱلْعُمْرِ تَهْوِى الْحَكْىَ وَٱلْحِكاياتِ. في مَساءِ كُلّ يَوْ...

1. باستخدام إطا...

1. باستخدام إطار العمل الحسابي "PVGIS-pvlib" لمحطة طاقة شمسية مرجعية بقدرة 1 ميجاوات، تم حساب إنتاج ...

أكدت مرجعية قبا...

أكدت مرجعية قبائل حضرموت رفضها أي مساس بالحدود الإدارية للمحافظة، ودعت الجهات المسؤولة والسلطات المح...

هدفت الدراسة إل...

هدفت الدراسة إلى تحليل طبيعة العلاقة بين استراتيجيات التفاوض ومرونة إدارة المخاطر والأزمات، بالتطبيق...

مفهوم السياسات ...

مفهوم السياسات التعليمية تُعدّ السياسات التعليمية من المفاهيم الأساسية في مجال الإدارة والتخطيط الت...

اختار اكثر المن...

اختار اكثر المناطق الجغرفيا السوريه اتساعا تمتد من الجنوب العربي نحو الشمال الشرقي مشكلة الحدود مع ا...

المبحث الأول: ا...

المبحث الأول: الإطار المفاهيمي والقانوني لقرار بلانكو يُعدّ قرار بلانكو الصادر عن محكمة التنازع الف...

U.S. citizen Ma...

U.S. citizen Mabelle de la Rosa Dann recruited Peruvian victim P.C. to come to the United States as ...

وفي ضوء ما تقدم...

وفي ضوء ما تقدم، يتبين أن انخراط الطالب الأكاديمي يتضمن بُعدًا معرفيًا يشمل التركيز والتفكير، وبُعدً...

A coin losing v...

A coin losing value by 30 percent does not necessarily mean it is a good deal, and neither does a co...

بعد وضع الاعتما...

بعد وضع الاعتمادات المالية موضع التنفيذ، يقوم الآمر بالصرف بإنجاز الجداول البيانية للأجور والمرتبات ...

Now, I will giv...

Now, I will give you a simple example. Suppose the teacher wants to teach the simple present tense. ...

أخبار التقنية