Lakhasly

مGاGNG نظN7ة

إH Hلبح+ 'H?لمN أGمNة GبNG )1N شتى 'Hم.اN gت?/ مN.GFة 'Hبح+ 'H?لمN مH' HمN'ضN? 'HتN g N.( إ>GاGHا با?تباG1ا 'Hقا?/) 'ل䐣ساسNة 'Hت7FN Nلق مGFا 'Hباح+ HلNصFN إHى 'FHتائ.'Hم'1/تحقNقGا.
1-ت?N7ف اHمنN.Gة:
سFق/NG Gما NلN ب?6 'Hت?GN1ا H'Nل>NNة g'Nصg7حNة GHلمة مGF..
1-1 ت?N7ف اHمنH .Gغة:
Gلمة مشتقة مN ".GF" Hت?N17H' NFق أH' NسبFN ('بH مN .)2003 ،1N8FتقابلGا H' NGل>ة 'ل䐥سب'نية H' MetodologÌaمG1بة مH' MÈtodo HتN ت?H' NFمH' LogÌa N .GFتN?N N/ أصلGا إHى 'FNNHاNFة "H' "MethodosمG1بة مH مق7?N odos HNت?N17 NFق N "mÈta"N ت?NF 'gت.اH'،Gبح+،'Hمتاب?ة،'8FHاH'،G/'1سة،(H'N)2013Nonikov&NonikovمقصN/بGا
?لG أP إGFا ?لH' GمFاN .G ب?با1) أخH' NG O1?لN P0H' Gبح+ NG 17ق 'Hبح+ 'H?لمN.

W :'/g77' .GFGF' GN7?. 2-1
W'.O7/.GW'GONF7W'N_F7FGW'6O 7?W'G67?WFNGNW/N/.W.'GNF?GF'WGN>F.WO/FN77WNGNW.GFGF'WOF'W/.7F W'NO.N.GW.'NGg.F'WOF'W.'GF7GF'WFGWgO F.FGWFNG.GF'WOF'WGNF?GF'WFGNW.?7F'WOF'WFG7F'WFGW&7'FF'. W )28W.7W1963WNN/.(W.'G7.7' .NW7'GGg'WG'.7F'WGF6WFGWNG
WNGW /?'7.W .'NFF.NW .'N.N.7' .7W'NWW .'N7.NW /N7>FNW /NGF?W 7'GG'W /?NG.GW F?W /7'.?W /N.GFGF'W F'W N' W W.//.WN'W/77' /W6'.F'WN'W/FN?GW/N7>FWN'W/7G'>W//7WOF?W/FG7.F'WN'W/FNF/F'WOF'WFN7NF'
: Methodology .GFGF' GF? GN7?.-2
W/G.F'W 7NGN.W ?GW /GNF?GF'W OF'W FN7NFFWF77F'W77N'WNGW//.F'.WNF.?NW GF?WGFW'.WNN/.F'W /G/GW GG7?NO WG'G/'W FGNW 'G.NN..NW /NG7?GF'W //'GF'W .N.7.W OF?GW GF6GW NF?NNW )28W .7W 1963W NN/.(W .FNF'N .FN?GWF'.GWNGWFN7..GF'W'GNF?WGF..NWgW/7N.6G W?NG.GNW /N6FGF'W G/GF'W OF'W FN7NF'W F.'W FGW //'.F'W 'G?..NW N.F'WFN77F'W /N.GFGF'W /?.W O7.'W /7'.?. W//7W G/?W N'W //7W FGW /G'.FFW ../F'NW /F/g'NW FNG7' .F'W GN/F.W NGW 'GW //'.W 'GG/..7NW N.F'W .'N/g' W''GF?F'WFN.W'GNF?WG7'?.GF'W.'NFf'NW.''7' .g'W/?NG.GWNGW/N.GFGF'WWF'GWGF6FW./FN?GW/N7>FWN'W/N67G WOF'WFN7NF'NW/G7?GF'W.'7.G'WNGWFNF/.F'NWG6GF'NW/>/gGFFW'GG'/..7'WFGGNWN.F'NW7'7..g'WFG'N WGNGW6N?NWN6F'W7N/GF'WNGW.'Fg?F'NW7NGg'WGGGW/FN'/GWNGW/N.GFGF'WFGWN7'7g'W67>F'NWF&'F/F' WFG'6GF'W F/W OF'W /G'6'W G7N7O.NW FNGF'W GG/.W N.F'W FNF'NFF'NW .'N7>FF'W OF'W FN7NF'W F.'W FGW F'7Fg' W ..g'.GF'WO.6WNGW/NF'7Fg' W'G?6'NGW Gg..'.W WGF...W W/N&6.W W.G'FGW WGNF?W W/.N.W WG'?F'W W.G'FGF'WGF?W .F'.WOF' W .GF?F'WWGF6WW/77' /WWNGWW'G?'..'WW..'NF'WW.'NFG?F'WW/N//.WW'GFGWWFGWW/GGGNWW.WGNF?F'WGg..'.
W ."Epistemology"WW"'N.NFNGN.7.g'W"WN'W"GF?F'W/G7FG"W.'?N6NGWFG6W.G'FGF'WGF?W.7/FN
W/FN77F' NG N'WW G//.. //'.F' GNFN F' ..N GNG FN.N N6F' GF?F' ":'GF'.W/N.GFGF'WN7G7?F'WG7?NN FFFFWN' GFG ''G.Fg' O./ G//. ?N6NG /N//.N //.F' OF? GG6? 6FG //'.F' 'GGF7N F' ..N N.F' W )10W.7W2004WN7G7?F'(W."G//. NG G/?'7. N.F' .'NFF.F'NW F&'7NF'N .'/'67g' /?NG.G NG
:/N.GFGF'N .GFGF' FN. F7GF' -3
?NN6NGF' /N.F'?G /NNGNG NNG '7'7' 7G>N NGGW'GFG N7'7' '6. NG N6F' .GFGF'WFG FG6' /N.GFGF'WF' G7' N6.7g'NWFNNF/.F'NWGN7NFFW7'7'W/.'/G.WNGNW//.F' '6' .' FG 'GGN //.F' /7.N F.GF' ON.7G OF? 'G7N7'F? F'NN. FgN. FNG NNGF?F' /N/.F'WG'N7F'N '6' N.' FNG. G.NG. NNGG "NNGF?F' /N/.F' NNG /NN.GFGF' 'NG' FN/G )11W.7W2004WN7GN7?F'(FG6F'.W/NFF?.GF' F&'N7GF' F? g6G 'GGG/. N.F' /?'NFF'NW 'G7N76N
2

WN6NF'W7N.F'W?NNFWGNFNF' .'NGg?  ?N.7' GF' /NG&'F FNN/N. /NNGNG  6G'NGF' NNG .'NGNF?GF'WFNN/N. /NNGNG W .777g'WGN>F.NW.'>7'GF'NW//.F'WG.W..GN
W
: //.F' GN7?. -4
."//."W/GFGFWN/g77g'NWNN>FF'WGN7?.F'WNFNW'GNGW67?F7 )2003W7N>FGWF.'(W.O7/.NW?...WO7F.W6.GWNF?. :/>F //.F' GN7?.1 -4
'G7/GN 'G.NGF.N 'GF? .NFF.F'NW /G7?GF' G'6.Gg /FN'/G"WNGW:'/g77' //.F' GN7?. 2-4 /NGF'?F'W/7'6/F' .G7 NG 7N7. NGF NG6 FG'G.G FG6. 'G67? G/ FNG? /FFNWFNF/ 7F.. 'GFNF/.N W )40W.7W2009WN.FN/FF(W."/FG'G /N/ /NF'7F' /GG'7G 'GNG GG'7. N
:NGF?F' //.F' GN7?. -5
F? GF6NW////G /FG6GF F/ OF' FN7NF' 'G.77'N. FGGN /77' /FF /FN7NWGF'. " Hillway ":N'NWFG GG7?N W."/FG6GF'WG6G. F7.. N.F'N 'GFG FF/.F' FGGN N.F' /F/g'N /G'N6F' ?NG.F FNF/F'N FG'6F' N7F.F' FN77 W )42W.7W2009WNN7?WO/FW7NG6GWNGW'GG( WN' /7' Gg' //?'7G N 'G/'?.'N 'G.'FNGGN ''N6g' /FNF/ F? N7/.F'"W :GFW'.W '6N'W .'/N.?W GG7?NNW WGG/?'7N 'GGW'GN/F N' GGN/F /FN?G /NGG' F/G. N.F' 7G'N>F' FNG6G N' ON./G /G7?G OF? .'77&GF' WG'/..7' /77'N. GF6 N '/'/F' 7/Gg' /N7'N7F' N /N/'7.Fg' N /N?'G..g' .gG6GF' F/ OF? W )5W.7W1999W.'/N.?( "./NF7FGF'N /NGF?F' .NF'7g'
:NGF?F' //.F' NG /N.GFGF' /NGG' -6
WN7'7'W77F?W/N.GFGF'WF'W'NF.W'FFWFN..W/NGN/'Gg'W/N/.F'W6'.F'WNGW/N7.6F'W'F..7..WOF?W''F. W'GGGGNW .'GNF?GF'W ?G.W OF?W /?'7.W /N/.W 'G.g'.GW Gg..'W OF?W /NGF?F'W /N/.F'W 6'.FgW N7N76N W7/GNW/N/FFF'NW/NFNF/.F'W/'7' FF'WOF?W/7/FF'W//'.F'W.'7G'WOF?W'6GNW'GGN>N.NW'G&'F.F'WF7/NW'G.N.7.N
W .FN.7.F'WF'.GWNGW'GF'G?.7'NW.&'.FF'WGNNF.NW'G.77' /NW.'N7?GF'
:NGF?F' //.F' G'/G' -7
./N/.W7'.F.7'WOF'WFN7NF'NW/G7?GF'W?N7GWFGW?7GWNGW//N/.W/G'6'WGN/F. - ./F.'7F'W/N/.F'W.N6.W/FWN.F'W7&'FFF'WG'G.'NW/7..FGWN'W/6G'>WGNG'GGW/76 - W/N6N.NW 'G.&'.FNW 'G.'.7'W /N//..W 'G7N7G.NW 'GGGGNW 'G7&'7.W G7NNW 7G'N>F'W GF..GW G7N -
.Gg..g'NW/.6F'WG.N'NW'G77'F?WFN.W.'Fg?F' .NF'7Fg'WG/F.F'WFN?.NW.g'.GF'WGF..GWNGWF'7Fg'WG.'N.WN.F'WFG'6GF'W6?.FWFNF/W/'.N' -
3

.//N.NGW.'N7?GWOF?W''F.W'GF.7W'G.W/7..7GW//N/.W.&'.FW7g..7' - W W.?N6NGF'.W'7'..7'NW/NF'/7GW'G7/G'W''F.F'NW/7GN.GF'W.'GNF?GF'WFGWF&'GF'WGGF'WNGWGG/.F' - :/.'FF' //'.F' .'G7 -7
W :/NF'.F'W7'FFF'WNGW/.'FF'W//'.F'W.'G7W7.FFWF'WFGGN
.FNNGF'NW7'7..g'WFGNW?N6NGF'W7'N..'W/N7/NW//.F'W6'.F'WNGW/N7.6F'W/.>7F' - .?.7' GF'W.'N>WF/GW//'.F'W67.?.W/FWN.F'W.'?7F'WFG/.FW7.7F'.WNF/.F'W - ./N7.6F'W'7' f'W''/.'NW/NGNFF'WG'G/g'W7'/7'WF?W/'?..g'NW/N.'6F'WFGW/7..F'W:/N?N6NGF' - .7'GGg'W/77WNGW/N6NF'NW/F/F'.WG6' .Fg'NW/N&'N6?F'WF?W/'?..g'NWG>FGF'W7NGG.F'WOF?W/7/FF' - W"'F'WO7'"W"'F'W.GF"W.7' '.?W.F..NWFNF.'7F'WFN//'.F'WG..GW'G?W?G7.F'WG/?WN'WNGF?F'W?6'N.F' -
WGNF.7WFN//'.W.'GNF?GWFGGNW'G'W//'.F'GW7G.7GWNGG7' .W''F.WF?W/7'.?W//.F'WFgW"/6W'F'" .'GNGW'N?FNW/FW''7.'W//7NWN'
W'G7/'7GWFGW'GNF.7NWN.F'W/GNF?GF'WFFFWNGW'FNG'W//'.F'WFNGNWF'WN'WFN.NGF?F'W/G6' FF'NW/F'Gg' - W/NG.W/F77WG/?NW/N7.6F'WG/NG.WOF?W/'G.?g'W'6GNW/NF'/7GFFW'N.N.W'G.'/7'W7G6NW/NFNF/F' W.&'.FF'W7NN6.WN'W'GNF'WFN7NF'WNGW.>7NWN.F'W.&'.FF'WFNF/.FW.'N7?GF'.W.?g.F'WN'WG7N>
..'FN?F'NW.'F'N..7g'N WOF?W7' 7F?WG/FNWgGWGFN7GNW//.F'W//'GNW//.F'W.FNWGN>F.WFg.WFGW7'.6Fg'NWGN>F.F' -
W'G.'7' FW FG7.W /N/.W NF7FGW FG6.W 'G?G.NW .'GNF?GF'W .N.7.NW //.F'W /7..W G6' .Fg'NW 7.& .6?.F'W'G6?..W'G7.7NW'G.?.'.GN
?.7' GF' /G&'F
W ./NGF?F'W..GF'W7'/W:.N7N.W..7?F'WF'7FW.)2003(W..W.7N>FGWF.' W ./N.7?F'W/6GFF'W7'/W:77GW.NGF?F'W//.F'W.G'FGW.)1963(W.?WNN/.F' W .?N6N.F'NW76FFFWF.F.7GF'W7'/W:F'G?W.)1999(W.GW.'/N.? W ./7G'FF'W.NGF?F'W//.F'W/N.GFGW.)2004(W.'WN7G7?F' W.''G7F'W7'/W.NGF?F'W//.F'W.G'FGW.)2009(W.GWNN7? W7'/W:F/7g'W./NFN7.GFg'NW/N/